Showing posts with label Stormwatch. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Stormwatch. Show all posts

Friday, April 5, 2013

Stormwatch #19

(w) Jim Starlin     (a) Yvel Guichet

Reading Stormwatch #19 made me realize just how invested I was with the 'New 52' incarnation of Jim Lee's classic team. Unfortunately, Stormwatch has been a low performer since it's first issue, most likely surviving the various title cullings due to Lee's history with the franchise. Enter Jim Starlin, who has -- instead of using what he was given to tell good stories -- decided to say "f*ck all", throw away 18 issues of character development and narrative, and start from 'scratch' with the classic iteration of the team more akin to the design in Lee's original concept.

It's bad.

There's no better way to say it. In a single issue, Starlin not only attempts to explain away the 'old' Stormwatch, but also introduce all the members of the 'new' Stormwatch and get them going on their first mission. 

It's asinine and, frankly, insulting.

If this were Stormwatch #1, I wouldn't have as big a problem with the issue's events -- it reads like a debut issue, and it could have made sense at the beginning of the 'New 52'. Now, it just feels like a shameless attempt to cash in on older readers who want to see their favorite team back together. There's no question that some regular readers of the 'New 52' Stormwatch are going to drop the book now that all the characters they follow are literally nonexistent. And what's the payoff? Some new readers who are familiar with the old Stormwatch? That's laughable, seeing as that audience would have no idea how or where this new, classic Stormwatch fits into the DC universe, et al. I can't figure out why DC would do this; why they would allow Starlin to do whatever he damn well pleases. 

I won't be reading Stormwatch any more. It's not for lack of interest. It's because at this point, continuing to read this series would be like getting abused and not getting out. Because in the end, it's disrespectful to readers who have spent their time and money investing in this series only to have it ripped out from under them. For shame, DC. For shame.

GRADE
4/10

Tuesday, April 2, 2013

The Week (Apr 3-9, 2013)

------- Spotlight
Thanos: Rising #1 of 5
(w) Jason Aaron     (a) Simone Bianchi
THE ORIGIN OF A MASS MURDERER STARTS HERE!

------- DC Reviews
Action Comics #19
(w) Andy Diggle     (a) Tony S. Daniel
SEE ANDY DIGGLE'S FIRST (AND MAYBE ONLY) ISSUE OF ACTION COMICS!

Earth 2 #11
(w) James Robinson     (a) Nicola Scott
TWO MAJOR NEW CHARACTERS ENTER THE FRAY AS "TOWER OF FATE" CONTINUES!

Green Lantern #19
(w) Geoff Johns     (a) Doug Mahnke
GEOFF JOHNS' PENULTIMATE ISSUE! THE FIRST LANTERN CONTINUES HIS RAVAGING OF REALITY!

---------- mini reviews
Green Arrow #19
(w) Jeff Lemire     (a) Andrea Sorrentino

The Phantom Stranger #7
(w) Dan Didio and JM DeMatteis     (a) Gene Ha
WHO IS MURDERING THE PHANTOM STRANGER?

Stormwatch #19
(w) Jim Starlin     (a) Yvel Guichet
JIM STARLIN BEGINS HIS REVAMP OF STORMWATCH!

------- Marvel Reviews
Age of Ultron #4 of 10
(w) Brian Michael Bendis     (a) Bryan Hitch
SEE THE RAMIFICATIONS OF LAST ISSUE'S TWIST ENDING!

All-New X-Men #10
(w) Brian Michael Bendis     (a) Stuart Immonen
GOTTA LOVE THIS SERIES!

---------- mini reviews
Indestructible Hulk #6
(w) Mark Waid     (a) Walter Simonson
WALTER SIMONSON AND THOR!

Tuesday, March 12, 2013

mini Reviews (Mar 6-12, 2013)

---------- mini DC reviews
Earth 2 #10
(w) James Robinson     (a) Nicola Scott

"Tower of Fate" begins this month in Earth 2 #10 as James Robinson introduces Khalid Ben-Hassin, the all-new Doctor Fate. A quick flashback reveals that Khalid initially rejected the power he was destined to hold, though his encounter with the helmet containing said power left him with sporadic and uncontrollable spurts of magic, as well as some sort of psychological issues. Robinson is doing a phenomenal job building Earth 2 from the ground up, making sure to focus on the entire forest instead of just the trees of the yet-to-be-formed Justice Society. The villainous Wotan also makes his 'New 52' debut as the malevolent, yet surprisingly polite seeker of the power of Fate for himself. All of this combines to make Earth 2 #10 a strong and impressive opening salvo to "Tower of Fate."

GRADE: 8/10 

Stormwatch #18
(w) Peter Milligan     (a) Will Conrad

Stormwatch has been an oddity in the 'New 52' -- it came out of WildStorm, it's not a very high-selling title, and it sits aside from most of the DCnU proper. With Jim Starlin taking over the title next month -- seemingly complete with a revamp of the title -- Peter Milligan brings his final arc to a close by ending the Engineer and bringing some closure to Apollo and Midnighter's relationship. Though it feels rushed, Milligan does a great job tying up some of the loose ends from his run, and we finally get to see that kiss between Apollo and Midnighter that's been building since they met. I've quite enjoyed this series so far, and Stormwatch #18 is a great end to a awesome run.

GRADE: 8/10

Superman #17
(w) Scott Lobdell     (a) Kenneth Rocafort

And just like that, "H'el on Earth" meanders to a close as ridiculously as it began -- with H'el no closer to his goals and us readers no closer to actually understanding anything about this inane new villain who felt more like a toy for Scott Lobdell to fling around and smack against things than a real threat worthy of any attention. I will always make time to mention Kenneth Rocafort's exquisite artwork because, at this point, it's the saving grace of Superman, akin to Michelangelo painting the musings of pimply teenager who think's it's funny to use 'hell' as someone's name. "H'el on Earth" has been nothing but annoying, and Superman #17 takes the cake for it's "payoff" of the coming of the Oracle, an entity teased for months only to sit there like a giant bump on a log and do absolutely nothing. In the end, it really should have been a Supergirl event seeing as she was the real focal point of the entire story with H'el, she helped him along the way and had to battle inner demons whilst doing so, then she makes a massive sacrifice in the name of justice -- instead, the entire event was a cobbled together mess that made little to no sense and ended with a big, fat whimper.

GRADE: 4/10


---------- mini Marvel Reviews
All-New X-Men #8
(w) Brian Michael Bendis     (a) David Marquez

A whole lot happens in All-New X-Men #8: the two Angels have their weird you-are-me-and-I'm-you moment, the Avengers get savvy to what's going on in X-Men Land, seeds of dissent are planted, and something happens on the last three pages that changes everything for this series going forward. Brian Michael Bendis again proves that his unique brand of interpersonal storytelling is perfect for the X-Men, and that his premise for the original X-Men living in the present is a lot more viable as an ongoing series than anyone anticipated. The emotional nuance present throughout All-New X-Men #8 gets down to the core of Bendis' story: these young X-Men are here to stay, for better or worse, and with all the hurdles that come with it. All-New X-Men is one of the best series Marvel currently publishes and it gets better every issue.

GRADE: 9/10

Iron Man #7
(w) Kieron Gillen     (a) Greg Land

Tony Stark's tryst into deep space continues with a lot of talking and a trial --  it's not nearly as boring as it sounds. Charged with over a dozen different crimes concerning his part in defeating the Phoenix Force, Tony receives help from an unlikely source -- a Rigellian Recorder designated 451 -- and takes his chances in trial by combat against the best of the Voldi warriors, which proves to not be as difficult as Tony imagined. Kieron Gillen's take on Iron Man is peculiar in it's hit-or-miss quality; each issue either impresses with it's wit and subtly, or fails at grasping what makes Iron Man so interesting. Iron Man #7 contains a bit of both, which leaves me satisfied at issue's end, but not incredibly so.

GRADE: 6.5/10

Tuesday, March 5, 2013

The Week in Revue (Mar 6-12, 2013)

------- Spotlight
Age of Ultron #1 of 10
(w) Brian Michael Bendis     (a) Bryan Hitch

------- DC Reviews
Earth 2 #10
(w) James Robinson     (a) Nicola Scott

Green Lantern #18
(w) Geoff Johns     (a) Doug Mahnke

---------- mini DC reviews
Green Arrow #18
(w) Jeff Lemire     (a) Andrea Sorrentino

Stormwatch #18
(w) Peter Milligan     (a) Will Conrad

Superman #17
(w) Scott Lobdell     (a) Kenneth Rocafort

------- Marvel Reviews
All-New X-Men #8
(w) Brian Michael Bendis     (a) David Marquez

Avengers #7
(w) Jonathan Hickman     (a) Dustin Weaver

---------- mini Marvel Reviews
Iron Man #7
(w) Kieron Gillen     (a) Greg Land

The Superior Spider-Man #5
(w) Dan Slott     (a) Giuseppe Camuncoli

Wednesday, January 9, 2013

THE WEEK (JAN 9-15, 2013) 1

FEATURED REVIEW
The Superior Spider-Man #1

Reviews
Action Comics #16

Earth 2 #8

Fantastic Four #3

Green Lantern: New Guardians Annual #1

Extra! Extra!
Animal Man #16

Stormwatch #16

Swamp Thing #16

Thor: God of Thunder #4

Tuesday, December 11, 2012

EXTRA! EXTRA! (DEC 5-11, 2012)

All-New X-Men #3
(Bendis, Immonen)

After two issues spent building up the return of the original five X-Men, Brian Michael Bendis takes a detour with All-New X-Men #3 to focus on Cyclops and his posse on the run from the law. Scott wants to set up a new 'Xavier' School in the remnants of Weapon X, which at first sounds terrible, but the more you think about it, the more rational the idea becomes -- Cyclops is using a symbol for hate and violence towards mutants as the location for a new revolution. My biggest problem with All-New X-Men #3 is that BMB does not know how to write Emma Frost -- usually, the man can write dialogue for women, but Emma is not a normal woman and that requires a certain voice to shine through, which it does not here. I've enjoyed ANXM as a whole so far, though this issue left me wanting and somewhat worried for the state of Uncanny X-Men when Bendis relaunches it in March.

GRADE: 7/10

Before Watchmen: Minutemen #5 of 6
(Cooke)

Before Watchmen: Minutemen continues to be not only the best title in the BW series, but also one of DC's best books currently being published--Darwyn Cooke's masterful blend of pop art and classic 1960s storytelling just makes sense for a group of heroes pretty much defined by those two elements. Minutemen #5 chronicles the quick descent of the team from a much-lauded crime fighting organization into a pale ghost of the glory they once had; things like Dollar Bill killing himself by mistake, and Mothman's alcoholism. In a last ditch effort to prove themselves to an ever-skeptical public, Cooke introduces Bluecoat and Scout, two comic book heroes in the flesh ready to help the Minutemen dismantle an actual atomic bomb. This vignette about Bluecoat and Scout is simply fantastic and a testament to Cooke's love for this series; instead of focusing on one, probably flimsy storyline (like, say, Comedian or Doctor Manhattan), he's treating this series as a textbook for the rise and fall of America's first superhero team.

GRADE: 9.5/10

Iron Man #3
(Gillen, Land)

Now I like it, now I don't, now I like it...that's how things have been going with me and Kieron Gillen's 'Marvel NOW!' volume of Iron Man--the first issue promised a fun, interesting variety of foes in Tony Stark's search for the Extremis bootlegs, while the second issue used that plot device to bring Gillen's weird neo-Arthurian dream to fruition before falling completely flat midway through. Iron Man #3, however, turns the tides once again in favor of Gillen and Greg Land as Tony goes after another Extremis owner in Colombia using his stealth suit of armor to infiltrate and retrieve the sample without being detected, albeit at the cost of more firepower. Gillen takes his time to explain why Tony is now using a variety of suits instead of the liquid metal armor capable of creating any weapon on any one of the separate models, and it's a fairly simple answer: something specialized works better than something adapting. The final pages are emotion-heavy, though Tony's dilemma may cause some readers to groan over the general trope of seeing the good being an evil deed.

GRADE: 7/10

Stormwatch #15
(Milligan, Conrad)

Harry Tanner betrayed Stormwatch and kidnapped one of it's best agents, all in an effort to gain more power and overthrow the Shadow Council that rules over Stormwatch and all of it's actions. Now, Tanner's returned (disguised as a Shadow Council member) to do just that and he's brainwashed the rest of the team into believing Midnighter is a mole plotting to destroy Stormwatch from the inside out. Peter Milligan's run on Stormwatch has been full of complex mythos, yet he can still write a damn good hissy fit between Apollo and his perceived heartbreaker, Midnighter. It feels like the climax of this arc is coming, as things couldn't get much worse for Midnighter, Stormwatch itself is on the brink of destruction, and Harry Tanner holds all the cards--this is a high-octane series that you really should be reading if you're not.

GRADE: 8/10

Tuesday, October 9, 2012

EXTRA! EXTRA! (OCT 3-9, 2012)


AvX: VS. #6 of 6
(W) Kieron Gillen
(P) Jim Cheung
(I) Jim Cheung, Mark Roslan, and Mark Morales

As an experiment, AvX: VS was a learning experience more than anything - it showed what creators could do under a different set of rules, some more freeing, others more strict. AvX: VS #6 showcases the best of what the series has to offer, with the main event between Scarlet Witch and Hope Summers not only taking the prize for most interesting duel in the entire run, but also giving readers more than just a fight, which is what we wanted all along. The latter half is filled with awesome one-page bouts that we didn't get to see throughout the Avengers vs. X-Men event, but in a humorous light (like showdowns between Jeeves and Toad, the science-y characters in the Marvel U, Red Hulk and Domino, Iceman and Iron Fist, and lastly, Squirrel Girl and Pixie, whose magic dice may have caused more damage than they anticipated). This was a strong finish for a tumultuous series.

GRADE: 8/10


Before Watchmen: Rorschach #2 of 4
(W) Brian Azzarello
(P/I) Lee Bermejo

While I very much enjoyed Rorschach #1, this second issue has really mutated into something I now don't want to read - somewhere along the line, Brian Azzarello decided it would be good sport to make Rorschach as much like Batman as possible, except here, Rorschach talks in two-to-three word sentences exclusively. I seem to remember that good ol' Inky Face didn't like prostitutes that much - going so far as to kill them - yet here, he's readily defending a woman of the night against her pimp, albeit to get to a bigger catch, but it's hypocritical nonetheless.  Azzarello is now batting zero for two with Rorschach and Comedian, the two least enjoyable books of the entire Before Watchmen line. Seriously, just stick to the other four (and upcoming Moloch) series because these two are simply unnecessary and silly.


GRADE: 4/10



Stormwatch #13
(W) Peter Milligan
(P/I) Will Conrad and Cliff Richards


I love me some Stormwatch - it's a series that, so far, has been set literally and figuratively at the fringe of DC's 'New 52' universe. Stormwatch #13 starts a new arc for the title, as Peter Milligan gives us more and more connections between the Stormwatch organization and the group of heroes banded together in Medieval times over in Demon Knights. There has already been a lot of foreshadowing that the Demon's Knights eventually become that era's Stormwatch, but here, Milligan finally brings Etrigan the Demon into current day continuity! Demon Knights has been one of my favorite titles from DC's 'New 52', and Stormwatch has been getting better and better ever since Milligan took over and stared planting the seeds of this awesome crossover.

GRADE: 7.5/10



Uncanny X-Force #32
(W) Rick Remender
(P/I) Phil Noto

Uncanny X-Force is so good, it makes me excited and worried for Rick Remender's upcoming 'Marvel NOW!' titles - I know Uncanny Avengers will be good, but I'm concerned Captain America will suffer because Remender seems to only be able to focus on one title at a time, as evidenced by his lackluster arc on Secret Avengers. Uncanny X-Force #32 is another brilliant chapter in possibly the best series Marvel currently publishes each month. "Final Execution" heats up as Deadpool and Evan (clone of Apocalypse) are confronted by the Evil Brotherhood of Mutants as Deadpool tries to break Evan out of their stronghold. Wolverine and Psylocke offer back-up, but times are looking grim for X-Force, as the premonition of Evan's ascension to the Apocalypse throne seems to be getting closer and closer.


GRADE: 9.5/10



Uncanny X-Men #19
(W) Kieron Gillen
(P/I) Dale Eaglesham


Uncanny X-Men #19 is "The Passion of Scott Summers", a look at what the leader of the X-Men was going through - internally - as he amassed the cosmic power and became the Dark Phoenix, ravaging the world before being defeated by the Scarlet Witch and Hope Summers. I typically don't like stories being told exclusively in formulaic first person perspective, but Kieron Gillen does an apt job convincing me that Scott Summers (of all people) is actually thinking these thoughts. It's incredibly hard to convey the idea of omnipotence (obviously), but Gillen somehow finds a way to come close by showing that even with all his power, Scott is still just a person, mostly unable to control or understand how that power actually works. It's sad knowing that Gillen is moving off UXM (due, mostly, to it's cancellation), but he's moving on to the newly announced Young Avengers, which gives me high hopes for the series.

GRADE: 8/10

Monday, October 1, 2012

THE WEEK (OCT 3-9, 2012)


Reviews
Action Comics #13
(Morrison, Foreman)
The Phantom Stranger makes a guest appearance this month, as well as Krypto: The Super Dog! I'm not sure there's a big fan base itching for Krypto to be included in the 'New 52', but Grant Morrison does, so why not.


Avengers vs. X-Men #12 of 12
(Aaron, Kubert)
It's the final chapter of Marvel's half-year-long event that's going to completely change the landscape of the Marvel universe. Okay, probably not, as Charles Xavier is already dead, we've had enough time to process it, and now we just want to see a cool battle between Dark Phoenix Cyclops, The Scarlett Witch, and Hope. Plus, we already know that Cyclops survives from October-December solicits, so what's the big change going to be? Well at this point, change for change's sake may not be so ridiculous.


Green Lantern #13
(Johns, Mahnke)
"Rise of the Third Army" is here, at last! Geoff Johns & Co. have been teasing this crossover event for some months now, and while the first Third Army solider was seen last at the end of Green Lantern Annual #1, it's time for the army to grow. Plus, new Green Lantern Baz makes his first appearance in his costume, and fights the Justice League.

Hawkeye #3
(Fraction, Aja)
Seriously, if you're not reading this series already, do yourself a favor and pick up the first two issues along with this third. Matt Fraction and David Aja have a clear and distinct vision for Clint Barton, and the first two issues are absolutely some of the best comic book work I've read in a long time (on par with Brian K. Vaughan's Saga). This is about Clint being himself, not an Avenger and not in the public eye. It's engrossing, relatable, grounded, emotional, and just plain great.

Uncanny X-Force #32
(Remender, Noto)
I finally started reading Uncanny X-Force and now I don't want to stop. Unfortunately, Rick Remender is stepping off the title he's taken two years to craft into one of the finest series currently available soon to focus on Uncanny Avengers and Captain America, both of which I'll be covering here on "The Endless Reel." The good news is, there's still a few issues of UXF left with Remender at the wheel, so I'll be covering these as well.



Leagues Beyond
It's the debut post of 'Leagues Beyond', the column that focuses on Justice League-related titles each week. This first week's offerings include two Earth 2-based titles, the eponymous series and World's Finest. I'll be talking about the formation of the Justice Society as they stand up against Grundy and the military-backed Atom, as well as Power Girl and Huntress' attempt to get back to Earth 2 via the boom tube that brought them to Earth 1!

Earth 2 #5
(Robinson, Scott)

World's Finest #5
(Levitz, Perez)


Shadowy Happenings
It's my first column of 'Shadowy Happenings' which covers all the 'Dark'-related titles DC releases. This week, both Animal Man and Swamp Thing delve into "Rotworld", each in their respective kingdoms to fight against the Rot and stave off a worldwide decay. In The Phantom Stranger, Dan Didio will introduce us to Raven, a character fans have been clamoring for since the 'New 52' relaunch, and the recent subject of Scott Lobdell's plans for an upcoming Teen Titans spinoff focused on a new team led by Raven herself.

Animal Man #13 - "Rotworld: The Red Kingdom"
(Lemire, Pugh)

Swamp Thing #13 - "Rotworld: The Green Kingdom"
(Snyder, Paquette)

The Phantom Stranger #1
(Didio, Anderson)

Extra! Extra!
4-SENTENCE REVIEWS are no more, as they are being replaced by 'Extra! Extra!', the section of titles that don't get standard reviews and also don't fall into an specific category of new columns. This isn't to say that these issues are any less good (or bad, in some cases) than the titles featured under the standard REVIEW header, it just means that I found a way to more eloquently talk about them in four sentences better than I could in four paragraphs. It's lika a haiku - sometimes creativity comes out of restrictions.

AvX: VS. #6 of 6
(Gillen, Immonen)

Before Watchmen: Rorschach #2 of 4
(Azzarello, Higgins)

The First X-Men #3 of 5
(Adams, Gage)

Stormwatch #13
(Milligan, Conrad)

Uncanny X-Men #19
(Gillen, Garney)